1963
1. Dick Allen (2)
2. Rico Petrocelli (12)
3. Cleon Jones (22)
4. Charlie Dees (32)
1962
1. Tony Oliva (3)
2. Tommy Harper (13)
3. Max Alvis (23)
4. Jim Hickman (32)
4. Bob Humphreys (34)
5. Manny Jimenez (41)
1961
1. Bill Freehan (3)
1. Sam McDowell (6)
2. Mack Jones (13)
3. Bobby Bolin (23)
4. Fred Gladding (32)
5. Bill Dailey (39)
1960
1. Juan Marichal (1)
2. Don Mincher (9)
3. Deron Johnson (17)
4. Dallas Green (25)
1959
1. Jim Kaat (5)
2. Zoilo Versalles (13)
3. Ken McBride (21)
4. Marshall Bridges (29)
1958
1. Frank Howard (4)
2. Leon Wagner (12)
3. Ken Johnson (20)
4. Sammy Taylor (28)
5. Ray Semproch (33)
6. Bob Schmidt (35)
1957
1. Roger Maris (1)
2. Don McMahon (9)
3. Curt Barclay (17)
4. Billy Muffett (25)
5. Red Witt (32)
1956
1. Luis Aparicio (3)
2. Ralph Terry (11)
3. Felix Mantilla (19)
4. Charlie Beamon (27)
1955
1. Herb Score (7)
2. Bobby Richardson (15)
3. Duke Maas (23)
1954
1. Harmon Killebrew (2)
2. Joe Cunningham (10)
3. Ray Narleski (18)
4. Karl Spooner (26)
1953
1. Jim Gilliam (4)
2. Gus Triandos (12)
3. Don Liddle (20)
4. Jim Willis (27)
1952
1. Hoyt Wilhelm (2)
2. Bill Henry (10)
3. Dick Hall (18)
4. Dusty Rhodes (26)
5. George Lerchen (32)
1951
1. Frank Thomas (7)
1. Dale Long (8)
1950
1. Dick Donovan (5)
2. Sam Jethroe (13)
3. Charlie Maxwell (21)
4. Johnny Klippstein (29)
1949
1. Minnie Minoso (3)
2. Wally Post (11)
3. Bob Miller (18)
4. Chuck Connors (25)
1948
1. Roy Campanella (1)
2. Ray Boone (9)
2. Satchel Paige (14)
3. Joe Ostrowski (17)
4. Neil Berry (25)
1947
1. Larry Doby (4)
2. Billy Goodman (12)
3. Hank Thompson (20)
4. Chuck Stobbs (27)
1946
1. Ellis Kinder (7)
2. Bobby Adams (15)
3. Bill Wight (22)
4. Marv Grissom (28)
5. Bud Souchock (34)
1945
1. Art Houtteman (7)
2. Erv Palica (14)
1944
2. Sam Zoldak (15)
1943
1. Andy Pafko (3)
2. Andy Seminick (11)
3. Cass Michaels (19)
4. Milo Candini (27)
5. Xavier Rescigno (34)
6. Joe Wood (40)
1942
1. Eddie Robinson (7)
2. Joe Berry (15)
3. Eddie Murphy (22)
1941
1. Virgil Trucks (4)
1. Phil Rizzuto (5)
2. Steve Gromek (12)
2. Dave Koslo (13)
3. Jim Hegan (21)
4. Pete Suder (29)
1940
1. Stan Spence (8)
2. Nick Strincevich (16)
3. Harry Walker (23)
1939
1. Charlie Keller (8)
2. Ken Raffensberger (16)
3. Bob Bowman (24)
4. Floyd Giebell (32)
1938
1. Sam Chapman (from Mil) (7)
1. Jim Tabor (8)
2. Joe Beggs (16)
3. Nick Etten (24)
4. Ernie Koy (30)
5. Creepy Crespi (35)
6. Pete Coscarart (39)
7. Heinie Mueller (43)
1937
1. Cliff Melton (from StL) (3)
2. Jimmy Brown (11)
3. Chet Laabs (18)
4. Ace Parker (25)
1936
1. Eddie Smith (from Mil) (6)
2. Al Milnar (12)
3. Eddie Mayo (19)
4. Eddie Wilson (26)
5. Jimmy Ripple (30)
1935
1. Ival Goodman (5)
2. Ed Huesser (13)
3. John Kroner (21)
4. George Washington (29)
5. Buck Rogers (37)
1934
1. Al Benton (7)
2. Denny Galehouse (from Paw) (12)
2. George Selkirk (15)
3. Jim Bucher (23)
4. Frenchy Bordagaray (31)
5. George Hockette (39)
6. Frenchy Uhalt (43)
1933
1. Lonnie Frey (6)
2. Dolph Camilli (from Stl) (10)
2. Bill Dietrich (14)
3. Frankie Hayes (22)
1932
1. Johnny Murphy (8)
2. Ray Starr (16)
3. Harry Davis (24)
1931
1. Bucky Walters (5) (from Mississippi)
1. Van Mungo (7)
2. Dixie Walker (15)
3. Billy Urbanski (23)
4. Les Mallon (25) (from Pawtucket)
4. Mike Kreevich (31)
1930
1. Hank Greenberg (5)
2. Pinky Higgins (13)
3. Pat Caraway (21)
4. to Pawtucket
5. Howdy Grossklos (37)
1929
1. Larry French (2)
2. Roy Johnson (10)
3. Doc Cramer (18)
4. Sam Leslie (26)
5. Al Grabowski (34)
1928
1. Lefty Grove (1)
2. Joe Cronin (16)
3. Fred Fitzsimmons (20)
4. Chuck Klein (31)
5. Buddy Myer (34)
6. Lefty O'Doul (46)
7. Bill Dickey (53)
8. Bill Walker (59)
9. General Crowder (65)
10. Watty Clark (80)
11. Red Lucas (84)
12. Sam West (95)
13. Carl Reynolds (98)
14. Don Hurst (110)
15. Carl Lind (117)
16. Les Bell (123)
17. Mel Harder (128)
18. Mule Haas (144)
19. Rabbit Maranville (148)
20. Rollie Hemlsey (159)
21. Pepper Martin (162)
22. Bill Doak (174)
23. Joe Stripp (181)
24. Tom Zachary (187)
25. Danny MacFayden (193)
26. Randy Moore (208)
27. Gene Robertson (211)
28. Johnny Gooch (220)
29. Walt Lerian (222)
30. Jack Rothrock (231)
31. Clint Brown (232)
32. Dutch Henry (237)
33. Art Delany (240)
34. Bill Hunnefield (245)
35. George Burns (247)